Archive for the ‘Commentary’ Category

Huppethal describes tax credits as “support level” for private schools

Tuesday, April 27th, 2010

During debate in the Senate today over a private school tax credit measure, State Sen. John Huppenthal described tax credit dollars as a “support level” for private schools, saying:

“The support level for district schools is roughly $9,400 with all spending included, while the support level for private schools is about $600…this inflator is designed to make things a little more fair.”

Huppenthal said this in response to a line of questioning by Sen. Debbie McCune Davis of Phoenix, who wondered correctly why the bill includes an annual inflation adjustment for the amount a couple or individual can contribute each year. Naturally, this adjustment only permits upward growth of the limit. Sen. McCune Davis then asked him if she understood him to be advocating for state support of private schools, to which he responded that he believed that parents should be provided a specific dollar amount to use wherever they please, be it pulic, private, or religious schools. We in public education have a word for this. It’s known as a voucher. Huppenthal concluded by stating that

“All children are created equal in the eyes of God, and deserve equal support.”

Penny also believes that all children are created equal, which is why every child deserves the highest quality public school system that we can give to them. Private schools should remain private.

Brewer Slights Teachers, Diminishes Quality

Wednesday, April 21st, 2010

This morning, Gov. Jan Brewer signed HB2227, a measure that is a direct assault on Arizona’s most experienced teachers, proving once again that politics are more important to our current administration than keeping our most experienced teachers in our classrooms.

In adopting the FY2010 budget, the Legislature enacted several provisions aimed directly at teachers who dared to apply political pressure to Legislators to support public education in budget negotiations. In response to this blatant retaliation, the Arizona Education Association filed a lawsuit challenging the legitimacy of these changes, which included prohibiting employment policies based on seniority, and removing the requirement that teachers be re-hired in the order that they are laid off. Now, instead of an effort to reach a compromise, we have HB2227, which is nothing more than a mean-spirited measure to negate the pending lawsuit.

Meanwhile, school districts are laying off hundreds of teachers in response to budget cuts enacted by the Legislature, and the first ones to go are the most experienced (e.g. most expensive) educators. Without the requirement that previously laid off teachers be rehired prior to new ones, cheap labor is the name of the game. Simple economics dictate that you can hire two brand-new teachers for the price of one 30-year educator. The difference is that now those first-year teachers are going to be given classes of 35-40 students, perhaps even more. This is a disservice not only to our students, but to the new teachers as well. Without the experienced educators that they replaced to turn to, a novice teacher with a huge class will quickly burn out and likely leave the profession, worsening the already critical issue of teacher retention.

And where is our Superintendent of Public Instruction, Tom Horne? Out running for Attorney General. We need a Superintendent who will stand up for teachers and students when necessary. Politicians, political consultants, and lobbyists have occupied this post for the last 20 years, each time using it to jumpstart a political career instead of fight for public education. Enough is enough. Please help the campaign today by donating or volunteering. Together we will make a difference!

Education: The great equalizer

Thursday, October 1st, 2009

Much is said about the value of education in America. It’s the stuff that “creates opportunities,” or “opens doors,” or “lets you fulfill your dreams.” All these things are true, but we rarely stop to think about why they are true. When we talk about these things, we are really talking about equity. We believe in the idea that no child will be placed at a disadvantage because they were denied the opportunity to learn the things that will make them successful. Just going to school and learning something is not enough to achieve this. The quality of instruction must be evenly distributed accross the entire spectrum. If not, then the benefits of a quality education accrue only to those fortunate enough to go to higher-quality schools. When this happens, the public education system no longer “opens doors” for everyone.

Children, of course, are in a poor position to determine for themselves whether they are getting a quality education or not.  It’s up to their parents, guardians, teachers, administrators, lawmakers, etc. to advocate for them. And those people don’t always agree on what “high-quality means” or how much it should cost. But this much is certain: adults are empowered to act today to make a difference in public education. And if we don’t, we are not contributing to a successful future. U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan said as much in a recent speech to educators.

“Educational equity is social equity. When children don’t have it, they’re condemned to failure because adults haven’t given them the opportunity to be successful.”

This campaign is about action. Arizona’s adults need to do what they can right now in order to ensure success for Arizona’s children. The parallel themes of High Standards and High Expectations are driving everything that we do, and will be carried right into the office of Superintendent of Public Instruction. For too long, the public education system has been maligned as the problem, when in fact it is the only available solution for the vast majority of Arizona’s youth. Neighborhood schools need to be both accountable and supported. The message should not be “Our local school is broken, isn’t that a shame?” but rather “our local school is in trouble, how can we help?”

There is a reason that professional educators use the phrase “supporting student success.” Years of experience has taught them that even the most disadvantaged or challenging students will take it upon themselves to learn if a proper foundation is laid for them, and no two students are the same. If a school is filled with hundreds or thousands of students, none of whom are the same, it would also follow that schools themselves are not the same. We must support school success by providing them with professionals who are trained to support many different types of students and who are willing to stay in difficult schools because they feel the community supports their work. Arizona has many challenges ahead. But nothing about those challenges prevents us from standing up today and declaring that we, as adults, are committed to supporting public education’s success, so that all children can have its full benefit. If you would like to join us, please volunteer or donate right now!

Join The Campaign

Join The CampaignDo you share Penny's vision of setting high standards and high expectations and building a better school system for Arizona? Take action today and help Penny put the public back in public education by donating, signing up to volunteer, joining us on Facebook or following us on Twitter! Penny needs you to help her lead Arizona's schools!